1D 35 vs Comet 33 S
Compare up to 4 boats side by side.
On the numbers
Next to the 1D 35, the Comet 33 S is 0.5 m shorter and 11% heavier. The 1D 35 has the higher D/L (94, ultralight), the Comet 33 S the lower (92, ultralight). The Comet 33 S has the higher Comfort ratio (14.0, lightweight racing), the 1D 35 the lower (13.2, lightweight racing). They have the same Capsize screening (2.30).
1D 35
|
Comet 33 S
|
|
|---|---|---|
| General | ||
| Builder | Carroll Marine | Comar |
| Designer | Nelson/Marek | Sergio Lupoli |
| Hull type | Fin w/bulb & spade rudder | Fin w/bulb & spade rudder |
| Rigging | Fractional Sloop | Fractional Sloop |
| Construction | FG | FG |
| First built | 1998 | 2003 |
| Last built | 2001 | – |
| Number built | 48 | – |
| Dimensions | ||
| Length overall | 10.67 m ▲ | 10.20 m ▼ |
| Waterline length | 9.60 m ▼ | 9.99 m ▲ |
| Beam | 3.28 m ▼ | 3.35 m ▲ |
| Draft (max) | 2.31 m ▲ | 1.80 m ▼ |
| Headroom | 1.62 m | – |
| Weight & ballast | ||
| Displacement | 2,971 kg ▼ | 3,300 kg ▲ |
| Ballast | 1,145 kg ▼ | 1,350 kg ▲ |
| Ballast type | Lead | – |
| Sail plan | ||
| Sail area | 62.90 m² | – |
| Mainsail | 38.34 m² | – |
| Foresail | 24.56 m² | – |
| Engine & tanks | ||
| Engine make | Yanmar | Lombardini |
| Engine power | 19 HP ▼ | 20 HP ▲ |
| Fuel | 45 L ▼ | 120 L ▲ |
| Water | 159 L ▲ | 150 L ▼ |
| Ratios | ||
| SA/D | 31.0 high-powered | – |
| D/L | 94 ▲ ultralight | 92 ▼ ultralight |
| Ballast/Disp | 38.6% ▼ moderate | 40.9% ▲ high |
| Comfort ratio | 13.2 ▼ lightweight racing | 14.0 ▲ lightweight racing |
| Capsize screening | 2.30 ▲ above the guideline | 2.27 ▼ above the guideline |
| S-number | 6.5 | – |
| Hull speed | 7.52 kn ▼ | 7.67 kn ▲ |
▲ highest and ▼ lowest value in each row. Ratio bands as on the yacht pages; – means the value is not in the catalogue.