Catalina 42 vs Saare 41.2

Compare up to 4 boats side by side.

On the numbers

Next to the Catalina 42, the Saare 41.2 is 0.3 m shorter and of similar displacement. The Catalina 42 has the higher D/L (196, light), the Saare 41.2 the lower (184, light). The Saare 41.2 has the higher Comfort ratio (27.8, coastal cruiser), the Catalina 42 the lower (25.4, coastal cruiser). The Catalina 42 has the higher Capsize screening (2.03, above the guideline), the Saare 41.2 the lower (1.88, meets the common offshore guideline).

Catalina 42 Catalina 42 Saare 41.2 Saare 41.2
General
Builder Catalina Yachts Saare Yachts
Designer Nelson/Marek / Catalina –
Hull type Fin w/spade rudder Monohull
Rigging Masthead Sloop –
Construction FG –
First built 1989 –
Last built 1995 –
Number built 477 –
Dimensions
Length overall 12.76 m ▲ 12.50 m ▼
Waterline length 10.97 m ▼ 11.20 m ▲
Beam 4.22 m ▲ 3.92 m ▼
Draft (max) 1.83 m ▼ 2.00 m ▲
Draft (min) – 1.80 m
Weight & ballast
Displacement 9,299 kg ▼ 9,300 kg ▲
Ballast 3,765 kg ▼ 3,900 kg ▲
Sail plan
Sail area 74.04 m² ▼ 87.60 m² ▲
Mainsail 33.66 m² ▼ 48.00 m² ▲
Foresail 40.38 m² ▲ 39.60 m² ▼
Engine & tanks
Engine make Yanmar Yanmar
Engine power 44 HP –
Fuel 148 L ▼ 310 L ▲
Water – 330 L
Ratios
SA/D 17.1 moderate –
D/L 196 ▲ light 184 ▼ light
Ballast/Disp 40.5% ▼ high 41.9% ▲ high
Comfort ratio 25.4 ▼ coastal cruiser 27.8 ▲ coastal cruiser
Capsize screening 2.03 ▲ above the guideline 1.88 ▼ meets the common offshore guideline
S-number 2.8 –
Hull speed 8.04 kn ▼ 8.12 kn ▲

▲ highest and ▼ lowest value in each row. Ratio bands as on the yacht pages; – means the value is not in the catalogue.